By the team at Reed Roofing. Published . 11 minute read.
The metal roof vs shingles question usually comes down to one thing: how long you plan to own the house. Metal costs more to install and lasts a good deal longer. We install both and make money either way. For most North Florida ranch homes we’d point at metal, and here’s the honest math.
Which Roof Do We Make More Money On?
Neither, particularly. Worth saying before anything else, because most metal roof pros and cons lists you’ll find online were written by somebody who sells one material.
We run two roofing lanes. On the shingle side we’re a certified GAF contractor. On the metal side we partner with Tri County Metals. Shingle on your house is a good job for us. Metal on your house is also a good job for us. No thumb on the scale, and you can weigh what follows accordingly.
We do have an opinion about which one fits which house. That’s at the end.
What Does a Metal Roof Cost Compared to Shingles?
Metal usually costs more up front, and how much more depends almost entirely on which panel you pick.
On the cost of metal roof vs shingles, the published national figures give you the shape of it. This Old House puts architectural asphalt shingle at roughly $6 to $8 per square foot installed, and steel metal roofing at roughly $16 to $23. Those are the two that matter here, because steel is what we install through Tri County Metals. The same source runs the full metal range from about $14 to $41 per square foot, but the top of that band is copper and zinc, and neither one is going on a North Florida ranch home.
Those are national numbers, not North Florida numbers, and we’d rather say so than dress them up as local. Use them for scale, not for budgeting.
Shingle on the house, metal over the porch
The honest problem with publishing a local range is that the number which matters is the one for your roof. Two houses of the same square footage on the same street can price differently by thousands, because one has a simple gable and the other has four valleys, three penetrations, and a section of low slope over the porch.
So here’s what actually moves your number.
What Moves the Price on a North Florida Roof
Squares, not square feet. Roofers price in roofing squares. One square is 100 square feet of roof surface, and your roof surface is always larger than your house footprint because of pitch and overhang.
Pitch. A steeper roof is slower, needs more safety setup, and costs more per square than a walkable one.
Tear-off. Removing the old roof, and paying to haul it away, is real money. Layers matter. A roof with two layers on it costs more to strip than one.
Decking condition. Nobody knows what’s under the old roof until it’s off. Soft or rotted plywood gets replaced, and that’s usually the line item that moves after work starts.
Penetrations and detail work. Vents, pipe boots, skylights, chimneys, valleys, and dormers. Flashing (the metal that seals those joints so water can’t get in) is where the labor hours go.
Material and profile. On shingle, three-tab versus architectural. On metal, an exposed-fastener panel, meaning the screws go through the face of the panel and are visible, costs less than a standing seam panel, where the panels lock together and the fasteners are hidden underneath.
The gap between exposed fastener and standing seam is the biggest single swing on the metal side. Ultra Rib and Classic 5V are exposed-fastener profiles. TCM-LOK, SL-LOK, and Mech-LOK are standing seam. PBR is what tends to go on low-slope, commercial, and agricultural buildings.
If cost is the reason you’re reading this, we’d rather give you a written number for your actual roof than a national average that doesn’t describe it. That estimate is free and carries no obligation, and you can start it by calling (386) 752-4072.
How Long Does Each One Last in Florida Heat?
This is where the money question actually gets decided.
Metal is the longer-lived option by a wide margin. An average metal roof lifespan of 40 to 50 years is the figure commonly cited across the metal roofing industry, and inland North Florida is kinder to metal than the coast, since we’re not dealing with salt air out here.
Asphalt shingle is a different conversation, and the honest version is not the one printed on the wrapper. Two things are worth knowing. First, a shingle warranty covers manufacturing defects and is typically prorated; it was never a promise that the roof will serve for the number of years in its name. Second, heat and sun shorten the run. InterNACHI’s technical guidance on asphalt shingles is specific about why: roofing components expand and contract with every temperature swing, roofs exposed to extreme thermal cycling deteriorate faster than roofs that are not, and UV radiation damages the asphalt layer directly. The same guidance notes that light-colored shingles in hot climates probably last longer than dark ones.
North Florida supplies plenty of both. We won’t put a Florida-specific year count on it, because nobody credible publishes one, but a “30-year shingle” here is not a thirty-year roof and you should plan accordingly.
Run the arithmetic and it usually comes out like this. If you’re going to be in the house another thirty or forty years, or you want to hand it to your kids, metal tends to be the cheaper roof even though it’s the more expensive install. If you’re planning to sell inside ten years, shingle is often the sensible spend.
What Fails First on Each Roof?
Neither material usually fails the way homeowners picture it. It’s rarely the big flat part in the middle.
On metal, the fastener goes before the panel does. On an exposed-fastener roof, every screw has a rubber washer, and that washer is the actual weather seal. Heat cycling works the screws loose over years, the washers dry out, and water finds its way in around a fastener long before anything is wrong with the steel. Which is why we pay attention to the screws we buy. Our screw upgrade carries our 3-year workmanship warranty on the install, a specific and checkable thing rather than a general promise about the roof.
Painted metal from Tri County Metals also carries a 30-year fade guarantee, and their Defender Series paint systems come in cool-roof colors, across the Core Defender, Max Defender, and Coastal Defender lines. A cool roof is one whose surface stays cooler in the sun and moves less heat into the house below, which is worth more here than it would be further north.
On shingle, it’s granules and sealant. The granules on the surface are the shingle’s sunscreen. Once heat and weather have worn enough of them off, the asphalt underneath ages fast. Meanwhile the sealant around vents and pipe boots dries out and cracks, and that’s where most shingle-roof leaks start. Neither failure is dramatic. Both are cheap to catch early and expensive to catch late.
We install GAF on the shingle side, and we register the GAF warranty at our own cost, which most contractors either skip or bill the homeowner for. GAF shingles carry GAF’s own limited lifetime warranty. GAF also offers upgraded system warranties on installs that use a qualifying number of GAF components together on the same roof. If you want that cover, ask about it before the job, because it has to be specified up front.
Are Metal Roofs Loud in the Rain?
Less than people expect. A metal roof over solid decking and underlayment (the water-resistant layer that goes down before the roofing) sounds different from shingle in heavy rain, but nothing like a metal barn. The barn sound comes from panels over open purlins with nothing underneath.
Some people like it. Most stop noticing after the first month. It’s a real difference and we’d rather describe it honestly than tell you it doesn’t exist.
Do Insurance Companies Like Metal Roofs?
Here’s the part most articles get wrong.
Florida law does require insurers to offer wind mitigation discounts on the windstorm portion of your premium. But those credits are documented on a state-approved Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection form, and what that form scores is how the roof is built and attached: deck attachment, roof-to-wall connection, roof covering code compliance, roof geometry, and secondary water resistance. The Florida Department of Financial Services publishes a consumer guide to those discounts.
Notice what isn’t on the list. Metal versus shingle, as a material choice, is not what earns the state-mandated credit. Any premium difference for choosing metal is a carrier underwriting decision rather than something the law hands you.
So ask your agent directly, before you choose the material. You’ll find metal roof insurance discount figures all over the internet, and every one we’ve traced goes back to somebody selling metal roofs.
Does a Metal Roof Help With Resale?
Possibly, and it depends on the buyer and the market.
The Metal Roofing Alliance says homeowners typically recoup 50 to 75 percent of a metal roof’s cost at resale, depending on the region. The same source reports metal’s share of the residential re-roofing market rising from 3 percent in 1998 to 18 percent in 2022. Those are the industry association’s figures rather than ours, and they describe a national market rather than your street.
What we’d say from the ground in Columbia County is simpler. A newer roof of either material sells a house more easily than an old one, and a buyer who sees a metal roof generally understands they won’t be replacing it.
Which One Would We Put on Our Own House?
Metal, on most North Florida ranch homes.
The typical house out here is single story, has a simple roof line, and gets sold or handed down rather than flipped. That’s exactly where metal’s longer life pays for itself, and the simple roof line keeps the install cost from running away. Add the heat, which is harder on asphalt than on steel, and metal wins the long game more often than not around here.
Shingle is still the right answer in plenty of cases. A complicated roof with a lot of valleys and dormers narrows the cost gap in shingle’s favor. A house you’re selling in a few years doesn’t need a fifty-year roof. Some HOAs settle it for you. And GAF architectural shingle is a genuinely good product, well installed and properly ventilated.
That’s the honest split. And if your roof still has years left in it, we’ll tell you that too, and this decision can wait.
Questions we get
Frequently Asked Questions
Short answers. If yours is not here, call the office at (386) 752-4072.
Cost up front, and after that the fasteners on an exposed-fastener system. The panels outlast almost everything else on the house, but the screws and their rubber washers are a maintenance item and eventually need attention. Standing seam avoids that by hiding the fasteners, and costs more to do so.
Usually not to install. Over a long enough ownership window it often works out cheaper per year, because you’re buying one roof instead of two. The break-even depends on how long you’re staying in the house, which makes it a personal question rather than a general one.
The install price, the sound difference in heavy rain, fastener maintenance on exposed-fastener profiles, and the fact that a good metal install needs a crew that fits metal regularly. Denting is a fair question too, though it depends heavily on panel gauge and profile.
Ten roofing squares is a small job. Run it against the national per-square-foot figures above and the answer comes out very wide, because standing seam and exposed fastener sit a long way apart. Published averages also miss badly on small roofs, since setup and haul-away spread over fewer squares.
Same variables, scaled up. Worth knowing: a 2,000 square foot house does not have 2,000 square feet of roof. Pitch and overhang push the roof area higher, and that larger number is what the price is built from. We’ll measure it and put a figure in writing at no charge.
We haven’t seen that here. Metal is common in North Florida, buyers recognize it, and a roof with decades left is easier to sell than one near the end. Appraisal effects vary by market, so a local agent is the better source on your street.
Carriers set their own roof-age thresholds and they differ between carriers. Florida Statute 627.7011 draws its line at fifteen years: below that, roof age alone can’t be the sole reason to refuse to issue or renew, and at fifteen or older the insurer has to let you pay for an inspection by an authorized inspector first. That’s the statute rather than a rule about your policy, so ask your agent. We’ve written more about the roof letter from your insurance company if that’s what brought you here.
Getting a Real Number
The comparison above gets you most of the way. The last part needs somebody on the roof.
We’ll come out, measure it, look at the decking, and give you a written estimate for both materials if you want them side by side. No charge, no obligation, and nobody sits in your kitchen waiting for a decision.
Reed Roofing is the roofing division of Reed McDaniel Construction, Inc., roofing out of Lake City since Don Reed started the company in 1973. Licensed and insured, Florida certified roofing contractor CCC1330719. We work across Columbia, Suwannee, Hamilton, Lafayette, Union, Baker, Gilchrist, and Alachua counties, including Live Oak, Fort White, Branford, Jasper, White Springs, and High Springs.
For most homes around Lake City, a screw-down metal roof is the one we'd suggest. It costs a lot less than standing seam, it goes on faster, and it's the metal roof we install most.
Hurricane roofing readiness mostly comes down to things you can check from the yard: loose shingles or screws, lifted flashing, full gutters, and limbs over the roof.
Want a straight answer about your roof?
We come out, get on the roof, and put what we find in writing. No charge, no obligation, and nobody waits at your kitchen table for a signature.